Welcome to Monte Carlo Italian Kitchen
Monte Carlo Italian Kitchen, located in Westerville, OH, offers a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of classic Italian dining scenes. Specializing in traditional Italian fare, their dishes are marked by rich red sauces and hearty portions, perfect for those craving authentic flavors. Diners rave about standout items like the chicken parmigiana and lasagna, both prepared with care and served alongside freshly baked bread and garlic sticks. The attentive service, highlighted by friendly staff, enhances the overall experience, making it a family-friendly spot. Monte Carlo Italian Kitchen is a go-to destination for anyone looking to indulge in comforting Italian food.
Monte Carlo Italian Kitchen: Reviews & Ratings
Had a pretty dang good chicken parmigiana. This place serves more "traditional" style Italian, (Think mobster movie dinner scene) with the heavy red sauce. This is not "Tuscan fare," or anything like that, so if you're expecting something "light," it may not be your thing. Food was really good. It tastes like you want it to. Service was excellent, and that's with 1 server working the entire room of 6 or 7 tables. No complaints... I'll be back, for sure
My review starts with the beginning of our evening with our lively/quirky waitress, Cindy! We enjoyed her commentary and the thoroughness of her attention to our needs. My caesar salad and my husbands wedding soup came out prior to the meal, which is how I feel it should be. Both were great. Both the Italian bread and the garlic sticks were warm and soft. I had the eggplant Parmesan with the penne and mushroom marinara sauce which had been prepared exactly as I had asked for it to be! My husband had the lasagna which he gave his rave reviews to. Thank you Monte Carlo for the excellent food and dining experience.
We went about 7 o’clock and it was not too busy. We had great service as soon as we walked in the door and the servers were very attentive throughout! I ordered the chicken parmigiana with penne; it was delicious! We also ordered the Monte Carlo trio and it was delicious too!! Both were very rich with an amazing red sauce. If we are ever back in the area we’d definitely go back! Very family friendly place with a great atmosphere and very welcoming!
My husband and I ate here this evening and had a lovely time. Everything came out very quickly and was absolutely delicious! I had the penne with red sauce- and an added meatball (good choice!). Husband got the chicken parm- it was super crispy. I also want to say something about our server. She, despite having to deal with a difficult table, was still smiling, attentive, and joking with us. And I will just say that table, who I overheard laughing and bashing the restaurant as they crafted their scathing revenge review about some free bread... They were children so I wasn't taking it too seriously, but was severely disappointed by the adult with them who could have used it as an opportunity for a lesson in grace and humility but instead said nothing
This is a great local Italian restaurant. It is not pretentious. The food is flavorful and fresh. My wife raved about the meatballs. I grew up with my Sicilian grandparents who did lots of home cooking from dcratch. Monte Carlo rates highly against my memories
Really enjoyed dinner here. Had a Hawaiian pizza with pepperoni instead of ham on a gluten free crust. It was so yummy! They also had Gluten free pene, but no actual gluten free protein to put in there, I am guessing from the preparation of it. Service was excellent and they dealt with large groups very well. Will definitely be going back!!
First time dining here. The food was all delicious. Had gnocchi with meat sauce and cheesy garlic bread. Service was good and pleasant. Sadly they were out of cannoli today. I will surely go again.
If good food is your interest, this is a great place. Old style recipes and lots of it. The lasagna may be the best in Columbus at any price. Not much as far as atmosphere is concerned. I like the quite environment and it makes it easy to have a conversation with your dinner guest. Prices are very reasonable.
Location
-
610 W Schrock Rd, Westerville, OH 43081, United States Hotline: +1 614-890-2061
Welcome to Monte Carlo Italian Kitchen, where traditional Italian cuisine meets an inviting atmosphere in Westerville, Ohio. Nestled at 610 W Schrock Rd, this delightful eatery is a gem for those who relish hearty, authentic dishes reminiscent of a lively Italian gathering. With a reputation for serving deeply flavorful fare, Monte Carlo isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience that transports you straight to the heart of Italy.
When you step into Monte Carlo, you are greeted by warm service and a cozy ambiance that feels like home. As Bob Spangler aptly puts it, the restaurant delivers a "traditional" style of Italian cooking. Think of it as the setting for a classic mobster dinner scene, complete with rich, hearty red sauce that envelops expertly cooked dishes. The chicken parmigiana here is a crowd favorite—crispy, savory, and satisfying. It's clear that each dish is made with love and an understanding of authentic Italian flavors.
Customers like Nancy S. have praised not only the food but also the delightful service. The quirky charm of their server, Cindy, who attends to guests with enthusiasm, makes the dining experience even more enjoyable. The way the meals are presented—with both the Caesar salad and wedding soup arriving promptly—looks to offer guests a true Italian dining rhythm. And let's not overlook the garlic sticks and warm Italian bread, which elevate the meal to a new level of comfort.
Katelyn Edgar shares her enthusiasm over the Monte Carlo trio and chicken parmigiana, emphasizing their rich flavors and satisfying portion sizes. The menu here is family-friendly, accommodating children and adults alike, fostering an environment where everyone is welcome. Whether you’re craving something light or indulging in heartier fare, Monte Carlo's offerings, from the penne with mushroom marinara to the hearty lasagna, will not disappoint.
As Jerome King notes, the simplicity and authenticity of the food reflect home-cooked traditions passed down through generations. It is that familial warmth paired with fresh, flavorful dishes that set Monte Carlo apart from the typical Italian restaurants. The meatballs, a standout item, are praised for their robust flavor, reminiscent of cherished memories of Sicilian grandmothers cooking in the kitchen.
In summary, Monte Carlo Italian Kitchen invites you into a world of rich flavors and warm hospitality. It’s a celebration of tradition and a testament to how good Italian food should taste. If you find yourself in the Westerville area, make sure to stop by—your taste buds will thank you for it!